Best Horror Films of the 2000s

Though something of a self-confessed horror fan, I still feel as though I am behind many of the die-hard fans. I also seem to search and appreciate different aspects of horror than many others, and there are a few films from my own list that I can’t say I’ve really seen anywhere else. That being said, hopefully I’ll motivate a few viewings and discussions; it was a lot of fun to write. For reference sake, I’ve seen about about 50 horrors from last decade, and am also including a short list of top five films I wish I had seen before making this list.

Top Five Horror Films of the Decade that I still need to see

Session 9 (Brad Anderson, 2001)

The Hills have Eyes (Alexandre Aja, 2006)

Kairo (Kiyoshi Kurosawa, 2001)

High Tension (Alexandre Aja, 2003)

Mulberry Street (Jim Mickle, 2006)

10. The Mist (Frank Darabont, 2007)

A film that I personally find depreciates in value on multiple viewing; The Mist is far too misanthropic for me. Not even the heroes are noble or virtuous; they are not even weak in an appealing way. I just want to say, I don’t need likable characters to enjoy a narrative but to have such a larger number of people with few redeeming features irks the optimist in me who believes that people are fundamentally good. That being said, their dynamic and situation is fascinating enough to not only sustain the film, but make it one of the best horrors of the decade. The story unfolds in a way very typical of the invasion narrative, as characters are forced to co-operate in order to survive, and inevitably fail because of conflicting interests and egos. This film integrates both the military and religion into the relatively small space with great effect, highlighting both the power and powerlessness of the individual within the “machine”. The much debated final scene is really what elevates the film to new levels for me, as the bleakness is brought to eleven by the faceless human monsters who come to the “rescue”. The Mist reflects a contemporary distrust in the military, not only as potential “monsters”, but the dangers they can unload on the public without us being informed or able to properly survive. In essence, it is about their failures to protect us, and in that sense, the father’s failure to protect his own family seems like a very apt comparison within the structure of the narrative.

9. Trick ‘r Treat (Michael Dougherty, 2008)

I feel in many ways, that Trick ‘r Treat is at odds with many of the other films on my list; It is not particularly unsettling, preferring to channel the “feel” of the Halloween season, rather than the true nature of horror. That is not a criticism, as much as it is an observation. The film still has its scares, but they are mostly incidental, harmless and subverted by both the absurdity of the plot and the comic bravura that runs through the entire film. The film is not completely shallow though, and in its subversion of our expectations, it also manages to make a few interesting observations on the horror genre and its clichés. Perhaps the best example is the twist on the virginal college girl; the premise is set up stereotypically, having her chastised and teased for her innocence, and then preyed upon by the lusty monster. Though it is hardly the first time we see the expectation of the innocent female transformed or turned on its head, I think this one is done with a new level of creativity that is unprecedented. Though the reveal of what the “victim” is plays a large part in what makes the story so interesting, it is what it represents that is pivotal ; something lusty, animalistic and the fact that she did not have to be corrupted to reach that state, that it existed within her from the start… and that she embraces it completely.

8. Suicide Club (Sion Sono, 2001)

Not an easy choice, though often disturbing and disgusting, Suicide Club does not exactly fit a classical horror formula. The grotesque nature of some of the subject matter and the extreme (and not cartoony) violence elevates it to a kind of spectacle horror like many slashers are, or more recent “torture-porns”. The film escapes from all the natural inclinations of western horror, and is not only an incisive commentary on popular Japanese culture, but the profound effect the lack of individualism has on society as a whole. The film’s opening sequence is one of the most shocking of all times, and not only sets a tone, but defines every moment that follows. The mass, and seemingly, random suicide of teenage girls leads to government investigations into the phenomena, that only seems to be growing, as well as a huge amount of self-examination. The most disturbing scenes are the two mass suicides, the first being apparently planned, though no real explanation is offered… the second, a genuinely random act of school yard games. The film offers a theory about people distancing themselves from… themselves; that most of us live a kind of out of body existence where we are not truly connected to the lives we live and with the other people in our life. That we exist as cogs in a larger game, allowing ourselves to be swayed and moved by the currents of the information age. Though, hardly an endorsement of suicide, the film approaches the subject as a kind of perverse revolt over individual freedoms and power that is ironically as faceless as the existence they are protesting.


7. Drag Me to Hell (Sam Raimi, 2009)

Much like Sam Raimi’s Evil Dead films, Drag me to Hell is notable for its formal and aesthetic qualities rather than the strength of its plot. By that I don’t really mean that it is a “visual” splendour, in the sense that Suspiria is, but rather that the creativity of both the constructive of the scares, and the use of motifs is both potent and consistently clever. The story is fundamentally weak, though it works as a very effective vehicle for Raimi’s unique horror sensibility. The manifestation of hell is very different than that of the Evil Dead films, as it is largely internal, motivated by Christine’s moral degradation. As a result, it often seems that the evolution of the scares moves from being extremely external, beginning with very physical attacks that are often without precedent or strong instigation, to becoming an internal battle, often with dreams, and with profound effects on Christine’s state of mind and relationships.  The film is just unmitigated fun.

6. The Last House on the Left (Dennis Illiadis, 2009)

I’m still kind of baffled that I liked this film so much; it is a remake of a remake for heaven’s sake! The film is somehow good though, from the almost ethereal quality of some of the imagery (notably the use of water throughout the film, which is at once redeeming and cleansing, but also hides the truth) to the lurid nature of the parent’s revenge, it displays a kind of artfulness a-typical of contemporary mainstream horror. The film is downright dirty, often times extremely difficult to watch. It appropriately makes the infamous rape scene extremely painful and disgusting, focusing especially on the victim’s experience, rather than the gratuitous violence of her captors. The second half of the film is comprised almost solely of the parent’s revenge on the people who raped and attempted to murder their daughter. The violence is gratuitous, at once satisfying and extremely disturbing. It is fascinating to see their transformation, but their moral degradation is even more apparent. The film does try to have its cake and eat it too, but I think it is successful enough on a formal level to ignore any apparent tonal or thematic inconsistencies it espouses.

5. Frailty (Bill Paxton, 2001)

Though the film is overtly about religion, and the dangers of fundamental belief, the film is universal in its handling of family matters and the questions of faith and morality. Rooted in a Christian ethos, a father receives messages from God that instruct him to destroy the demons that live among them. He takes on the aid of his two sons, one who believes him without question, and the other who doubts him every step of the way. It should be no surprise that this creates an incredible amount of tension between the characters, and because the film itself never fully commits to what perception of reality is accurate or not, the audience is not only disturbed by the possibility that the father is insane, but that even worse, that he might not be. The film is shockingly brutal, without ever having to show very much. Most of the violence takes place off or just beyond the confines of the screen; the characters carry the weight of their actions, whether it is with a certain amount of disgust, or the sense of a dutiful act completed. It is a film that does a lot with very little, and relies heavily on both its writing and the strength of its performances… two things that more horror films could try.


4.Let the Right One In (Tomas Alfredson, 2008)

One of the more compelling entries in the vampire genre, Let the Right One, is an intimate and frightening story of the wolf and the lamb. It is entirely possible that this film could be read as a kind of love story, not unlike Twilight, where two bodies of the same age interrelate in a seemingly romantic way. This is a disturbing interpretation of events, but I do not think it is an illegimate one. If we want to be reductive, Wuthering Heights is also a love story, and so is Lolita. It is because love is seemingly involved that all of these narratives become so disturbing, because we do not want to believe something as sacred and holy as love can be so perverted by abuse, violence and obsession. In Let the Right One In, because of the appearance of the characters suggests pre-pubescent youth, it is easy to ignore the implied age of one of them. When they are both lying together in bed, naked, the scene is not disturbing because one is a vampire, but because we do not want to believe in sexualized children… even if Oskar’s own naivety implied little more than a healthy curiosity in the opposite sex, the imagery is strong enough to unsettle us. This idea is used recurrently through the film, and is a rather common one in the handling of children in horror. It just so happens that this film integrates it with a newfound melancholy and sense of loss, that almost serves to justify the character’s reliance on each other, even if one can only assume that at least one of them will be a little more lost for it. We both hope for Oskar and Eli to remain together, because they are both lost souls who seem to have found hope, while we shrink at the most likely consequences of this “union”.

3. Ginger Snaps (John Fawcett, 2000)

Horror is probably the best genre of filmmaking to deal with traumatic life events, especially ones that are commonplace. Ginger Snaps deals not only with the coming of adolescence between two sisters, “the curse”, but also the trauma of early sexual discovery. The film appropriately handles the complex nature of female sexuality, not only in the woman’s role as the submissive player in the male-female power-plays but how it is further exercised in relationships with other women. This is not only present in the idealized female friendship that exists between Ginger and her sister Brigitte, whose relationship borders on incestuous in their psychological and physical intimacy but in both girl’s interactions with their classmates. The aggression and rivalry displayed between the sisters and popular girl, Trina, reveal the nuances in both female competitiveness and even the sexual tension that exists between rivals, in how Ginger dominates Trina both physically and mentally, and then has the audacity to offer Trina’s “body” for her father to taste. It’s sickening and disturbing on so many levels, but yet, somehow un-gratuitous and natural. One of the great films about adolescence and teenage girls.


2. Trouble Every Day (Claire Denis, 2001)

As scarce as female directors are in the filmmaking world, in the realm of genre (beyond rom-coms) they are as rare as albino two-headed calves. Claire Denis is the exception that makes the rule, especially considering, that she makes a film that is so un-genre-like… pure arthouse fluff. Suffice to say, I love every minute. The film is exceptionally feminine in the handling of horror and violence; the plot is thin, but the anxiety and relationships are strong. The characters are in anguish, as the ones who are infected can’t help consuming other people “just to feel something”. Her handling of consummation is hardly different than her treatment of sex, and both are unconventional for any genre, especially horror. The perspective is that of a woman, the focus is on the flesh, touching, moving… it is not only focused on the female experience, but adulates the male form in a cinematically unfamiliar way. The film is not necessarily about violence, physical or emotional, between lovers, but about our self-destructive nature and how it poisons our lives. On an aesthetic level, it is a film about the flesh; a study of movements, deconstructions, comparisons, and filters. The body is seen in many states, through many lenses, in many locations… constantly transforming and taking on new meanings. It is a film like a dream, or more like a nightmare, it is an existence that you don’t want to believe… but fear does.

1. All the Boys Love Mandy Lane (Jonathan Levine, 2008)

A film that has no right to be as sad and probing as it is, All the Boys Love Mandy Lane, is at its worst, a self-aware and over-stylized pretentious film that attempts to over-compensate the familiarity of its structure with almost patently absurd visuals. Why include it then? Truthfully, a large part of me loves all that empty self-awareness; it is so descriptive of a sub-genre of horror that gave up so long ago. It is this premise of absurdity though, that allows moments of true intimacy and humanity to peek through. The characters are not only aware of their superficiality; they seem to strive to be the clichés of adolescence that we find so often in popular culture.  The men seem to recognize the moral corruption of their pursuits, how misogynistic and destructive it is, while the women pursue degrading situations that only further put into question their own identity and self-esteem. Both personalities are extremely vulnerable when isolated from the authority of mom and dad, and the comfort of not being brutally murdered by a faceless killer. The tension is palpable, the melancholy real, and the revenge brutal. For a film that works so hard to look like a magazine spread, the murders are not fun or beautiful, they are not even particularly creative… but that’s why they are so effective. They humanize the inhuman, and only further contribute to the re-evaluation of horror norms within the slasher genre that shows no respect for death or human weakness.

38 responses to “Best Horror Films of the 2000s

  1. Merci ours ❤

    I've seen The hills have eyes remake on quite a few other lists, it was putting that or The Devil's Rejects on my list and I wasn't interested in the latter. High TEnsion is terrible too, just watched it :/

  2. I actually quite enjoyed High Tension, and I’m not normally into slashers, although I’m still uncertain about that twist. I was less impressed by Aja’s version of HHE, which is OK but doesn’t really do much that the original doesn’t do; it’s most successful in the third act when it finally goes places the original didn’t.

  3. The Hills Have Eyes I thought was a great remake that retained the brutality of the original. High Tension is a very interesting slasher and I think it’s a movie that will ultimately piss off a lot of a people.

    Session 9 is an amazing, freaky, original movie and I highly, highly recommend it.

  4. I disagree that Mulberry St is bad. It had a great setup and characterization, and only really fell apart in the last 30 minutes or so.

    Session 9 is a must-see. Such great tension, dread, and atmosphere.

    If only we all had the time to watch every single movie we wanted.

  5. James: I am pretty meh on slashers myself, though I’m not sure I’d qualify High Tension as being one… though I suppose I could see where it is. It does fall comfortably with a few recent french films I’ve seen, notably A L’Interieur, which I thought was very similar… just a lot worse. At least I thought about High Tension, that the cinematography was pretty nifty and it had a few select moments of awesome. Mostly it made me feel too icky inside. The twist is somewhat predicated, but is mostly nonsensical and stupid.

    Patrick: I desperately want to see Session 9 but for some reason by video store does not have a copy :/ They have weird stuff, but not Session 9. It annoys me to no end. Despite me saying otherwise, I probably will still check out the Hills have Eyes remake.

    Chris: I might still see Mulberry St. Not too many other horrors of the decade that are high priority and I don’t see myself avoiding the 2000s forever.

    We never have enough time 😦

  6. I’ll have to take up this “Fraily” business with my brother. Bill Paxton is a sort of cult touching-stone between the two of us, “Aliens” being one of the films we inevitably bring up whenever we’re together (“seventeen days! . . . we’re not gonna last *seventeen hours* MAN!!”). His other Cameron-appearances get indexed often too. And I know he’s seen Frailty (I have not) so I’ll have to get his take and inform him there are passionate defenders out there!

    I’m going to smack myself here because I was thinking of “Switchblade Romance” and now I have the feeling that “High Tension” might be an alternate title so I’m going to have to find out what this is about . . . I’ll be back when I know how I’ve embarassed myself.

    Are the other flesh-eating movies of the decade, like Martyr or that French thing I can’t think of, within the frontiers of your consideration?

  7. Oh now I feel so smart! lol I knew it as “Switchblade Romance” because I read about it in Sight & Sound . . . I’m not sure how I even picked up the suspicion it had an alternate title along the way . . . Oh well, I’m out of the loop on a lot of things

    I’m still confident when I *finally* see Diary of the Dead I’m gonna come running here and yell “Brilliant!!!” *fingers crossed*

  8. The Descent nearly made the list, though admittingly, it hasn’t sat quite well with me. I still think the first half is just about perfect, but as a whole and especially the second half just does not sit as well.

    Jason: I think Bill Paxton should bring us all together, a God among men.

    Don’t get your hopes too high on Diary, nearly everyone I knew who saw it said it was an abomination.

    Aiden: I highly recommend all of them, thanks for dropping by.

  9. Loved reading this. I really need to see Frailty and Mandy Lane. My favorite horror of the past decade would probably be Ginger Snaps, Devil’s Rejects, or The Descent.

  10. It’s nice to see someone else who appreciates the remake of Last House on the Left. That movie takes away everything that makes the original interesting, namely the disconnect between the audience and the rape, and then replaces it with a bunch of other interesting material.

    Have you not seen Rec yet or does that not make the list for other reasons?

  11. Along with Session 9, I’ll eagerly recommend Kairo (ie. Pulse). It’s one of my favourite films of the decade. Subtle, creepy, beautifully framed and with a sound design that is unbelievably effective.

    Love some of your picks – Ginger Snaps, Let The Right One In and Frailty are all high on my list too. I think I need to revisit Suicide Club – I seem to remember really liking the first half and then really disliking the second half. But now that I’ve seen a few more Sion Sono films (the purposely over-the-top Hair Extensions and the phenomenal Love Exposure), I should circle back.

    I have to say, I don’t quite get the appeal of Trick R Treat. It looked great and had some good ideas, but apart from the final story with Sam, none of them found an even keel for me. They would try to be scary or tension-filled or funny or campy or retro and just seemed to fail in all cases. I didn’t hate the film, but I don’t think it’s designed anywhere near as clever as the director thinks it is.

    I’ve been wanting to see Trouble Every Day for quite some time now – I should really track it down. Beau Travail confounded me (just not sure what to make of it), but 35 Rhums was extremely effective and quite lovely. Denis certainly intrigues me.

  12. res: I really need to see The devil’s Rejects too.

    Joshua: I actually haven’t seen the original Last House on the LEft (only Bergman’s The Virgin Spring, which I recommend, because it trumps the remake in every way… so I can only imagine how much better than it may be than Craven’s).

    [rec] actually JUST missed my list, I even wrote a little blurb on it, as I was just about to include it before pushing something else in instead. I’m very donf od it.

    Bob: Luckily, I have a friend who just lent me a bunch of recent horrors, including Pulse. I should be seeing it soon.

    Suicide Club does drop in the second half, it gets almost too weird, but I still think it has enough value to rank it as high as I do. I actually think I might rank it at the bottom of Sono’s filmography, or I don’t know… beyond Love Exposure, which is by and far the best of his, the others shift with my mood. I am definitely a fan of his work though.

    I can understand that, but like Drag me to Hell, I think it benefited from a great theastre experience for me. Sometimes audience interaction just raises a film that is decent to something special.

    Trouble Every Day is still the only Denis Iv’e seen.

  13. I’ve been trying to watch all the movies on this best list, and I’ve almost seen them all. And, so far, none of them are really beating out The Descent (except for Let the Right One In). So, I have to wonder, did you see the American version or the original of The Descent?

  14. really?

    Totally rubbish choice for number 1, all the boys love mandy lane was good, i enjoyed it, but it’s one of those that just fades in with all the others.

    Let the right one in on the other hand was quality.

  15. Gosh, we have completely different taste in horror films.

    Reading through this, I was thinking ‘wow, this guys loves chicks in horror films’ and then :

    “The film is exceptionally feminine in the handling of horror and violence; the plot is thin, but the anxiety and relationships are strong.”

    *scrolls back up to look at the author’s name*

    oh. wait. It’s a girl! lol….

    Anyway I hated/didn’t care for “All the boys love mandy lane” (I thought it was derivative and pretty boring; nothing redeeming) but I might give Suicide Club and Ginger Snaps a try. Both sound harrowing though!

    Let the Right One In was really fantastic though; although barely horror; much more drama.

  16. All the Boys Love Mandy Lane was such a waist of time.The actors were weak, the story sucked, there was no reason for all the murders, the killer was shown by the half of the movie…it was all so predictible, and….the girl was not even that pretty :)))

  17. Excellent list. I’d forgotten about Ginger Snaps – all the way back there at the start of the decade. An excellent film – the first sequel was okay too. Frailty was a terrific film, what a shame Bill Paxton hasn’t continued to do more horror films as a director.

  18. I have been reading alot of horror movie favs from alot of different sites, but i’m not convinced. That said just want to say one word…SAW!¿!

  19. Watching Session 9 was one of the largest wastes of my life. The movie was predictable and dry. I expect some sort of psychological disturbances or chilling scenes but was left with nothing. I’d be interested to hear your take on it if you’ve seen it yet.

    Interesting list, I’m looking forward to seeing a few I’ve never heard of.

  20. I’ve seen half of the movies here and will definitely be watching session 9 ‘n mulberry.. My favorite so for is Let The Right One In and am quite surprised that The Descent and Martyrs didn’t make it and the top 1 is quite disturbing for me. It should me on the top list of worst horror…

  21. I really don’t know why you find Ginger Snaps repulsive, or incestruous. I loved it as a teen, I must have been emo before emo was a thing. But I watched it again recently and as A mother I am confused as to why these girls were so pissed off. They had a good life, a nice home, descent parents, WTF was their problem!? Their Mum might have been dippy, but she wasn’t a drunken abusive bitch. Silly emo lycans!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s